Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Butter Balls
Chicken Alfredo
Meatball Sub
Chicken Salad Sub
About
American Pie Pizzeria - Carrollton
Welcome to American Pie Pizzeria - Carrollton, a local gem nestled on Maple Street, where the aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the air and the community gathers to enjoy hearty meals. Located at 927 Maple St, Carrollton, GA 30117, this vibrant pizzeria is renowned not only for its delicious pies but also for its welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're a local or just passing through, American Pie is a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts.
As you step inside, you’re greeted by the sounds of laughter and shared happiness among families and friends. The expansive seating area is perfect for large gatherings, making it a favorite spot for sports teams and celebrations alike. The warm and engaging ambiance complements the menu, which boasts an array of mouthwatering offerings.
At the heart of American Pie Pizzeria’s appeal are its specialty pizzas, each crafted with precision and passion. Guests rave about the BBQ Bacon Double Cheeseburger Pizza, where sweet BBQ sauce meets gooey mozzarella, beef, cheddar, and crispy bacon. For those seeking a bit of heat, the Buffalo Chicken Pizza tops mozzarella with spicy buffalo sauce and grilled chicken, a dish that is sure to ignite the taste buds. And let’s not forget the Ranch Pie, a delightful fusion of ranch dressing, mozzarella, cheddar, ham, and bacon, making every bite a savory adventure.
But the deliciousness doesn’t stop with the pizzas. Their wings, available in flavors like Mild, Spicy BBQ, and Garlic Parmesan, have gathered enthusiastic reviews—the perfect starting point for your meal. For a heartier option, try the creamy Chicken Alfredo, served tempting with garlic toast, or indulge in the comforting Spaghetti with Meatballs.
The reviews from happy patrons speak volumes. Meredith Booker has declared her first visit a true success, while Donald Beckworth enjoyed a custom personal pizza after a bike ride—showing how American Pie fits perfectly into the active Carrollton lifestyle. Tiffany Anderson’s experience highlighted their capacity to cater to special events, delivering food hot and fresh, while Calvin Palmer offered a testament to the solid flavors that have kept him returning after years. Lastly, Zay Andrés emphasizes the dedication the staff has for freshness and quality, confirming that both the wings and pizzas are made with care.
American Pie Pizzeria - Carrollton stands as a testament to what a pizzeria should be: a community hub serving tasty, satisfying meals. Whether you're there for a casual dinner or a special occasion, the combination of delightful dishes, friendly service, and a lively atmosphere will make you feel right at home. So come on down, savor the delicious offerings, and experience why American Pie Pizzeria is celebrated as one of Carrollton's finest eateries.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Our 1st visit, and we will be back! The pizza was delicious! ”
“ Stopped by today after riding the Carrollton Beltway on our bikes. The wife went for a custom personal and I went for a medium Baked Potato pizza with bacon. Yummy. Service was prompt. Pizza was good. Can't ask for much better. Expect large parties in the evenings and weekends. Looks like the kind of place all the sportsball teams come after scoring all the goal units ”
“ We had the party room for a small baby shower. Private no distractions. We ordered 2 party pizzas and butter balls. Food was delicious! Delivered to the table we had set up hot and fresh! We did have to ask for plates and utensils. ”
“ I rediscovered this place after years and years, and the pizza did not disappoint. The pizza here is really good, crust is normally on thin side. I have only ordered pepperoni and sausage and the Alfedo pizza add chicken. I was just there last week: it took over 30 minutes for three pizzas, dine in, but two were Xtra large which may have contributed to the delay. This factor would have been better received if communicated. Their customer service skills are not the best and could use some improvements. ”
“ This is hands down the best pizza place ever in Carrollton GA I like how the employees take time to make sure their food is fresh and well made for customers like me. The tables are clean, the room is very huge and the atmosphere is very warm out here. It just suits this place well! I enjoy eating here & my main favorites of this establishment is the pizza and their wings! They were pretty tasty & tasted VERY FRESH! Bathrooms are very clean as well. No issues while using it. I ordered mild original wings and of course it comes with their BBQ sauce! The pizza itself was very cheesy and hot. I will continue with patronizing this establishment. I will definitely return. This is a must have if you're over here looking for fresh pizza, or if you're looking for delicious wings. ”
“ We had a good 1st visit. We will be back. The sauce is a canned sauce. However, it is one of the better ones we have had. Once they get the first customer in for the buffet at opening, they keep the pizzas coming. Their birthday cake dessert pizza is amazing!!! The restaurant was very clean. Bathrooms were both very clean. ”
“ I got my pizza to go but overall it was a good experience! Not really nothing to exciting to state other than it is more of a kid like atmosphere! ”